Categories

Showing posts with label ron silliman. Show all posts
Showing posts with label ron silliman. Show all posts

Monday, November 04, 2013

ModPo 2013 #58 Heteroglossia and a Long, Long Train of Voices: On Silliman's "BART"

Image of musicians at the Metro by barpfoto.com.

The link to text of Ron Silliman's BART is here.
--------------------------------------------------------------
There's something about trains that makes them a metaphor for modern humanity. There's Jack Kerouac's "October In The Railroad Earth" and Ezra Pound's "In a Station of the Metro." And on the personal sphere, I've written several poems set in train stations or in trains.

Here's one:

Sad Song at The MRT Station

Suspend the speed at which people walk,
watch them float on the concrete,
watch the drops of rain slant in the air.
Listen to the first tinny note
of the electric guitar.
It seems as if it is coming from nowhere.
A woman's voice blends with the guitar.
It's a song from five decades ago
filling the space, her voice is so close.
It comes back to you,
your grandfather singing the song,
"Kailangan kita" to your grandmother
who waves away his earnestness.
Your remember his eyes
bright with tears that will not fall,
his wavering voice.
You think he was alone at that moment.
But he wasn't. He is here, now, with you.

Come to think of it, I should have cut off that last line. But I digress. My point is: trains and train stations are living veins of the city. If you want a look at a cross section of society, you just need to ride a train. In Manila, sadly, we don't have a very organized public transport system. We do have trains but they are far too few and leave too many gaps in our city uncovered. We don't have proper bus stops and jeepneys (a leftover from World War 2, a common mode of transport, and a national symbol too) have a tendency to load and unload just about anywhere (that's a metaphor about the Philippines there).

Two years ago, when I was living a city away from my place of work, I was taking the train to and from work almost every day. That was quite an experience. I was too used to order that I quailed at trying to push my way into a car. Apparently, it was normal to do it then. Now, I hear, it's no longer the mode. Lines have been enforced (finally!). It's easy to be in a crush of people when one rides a train. I had some very Pound-like moments when I imagined each soul riding the endless lines of cars, each different but lit by some kind of energy that was invisible. It's true that a train has a tendency, too, to separate each commuter into separate spheres, each lost in a personal bubble of music or reverie. It's not a place to commune. It's a place to be separate and in transit.

I notice in my poem that people (and rain) become only the background to a memory playing out, prompted by the blind musicians who haunt the train stations with their tin cans waiting for coins from commuters.

In Silliman's project, he boldly writes as he commutes, a feat in itself. I've never written while riding a train. It's just impossible, at least in Manila. It's hard enough to carry myself and my purse through the crowds...what a luxury to have elbow room to write!

I compare this to Bakhtin's concept of heteroglossia and the chorus. By capturing "voices" including the speaker's, power structures and the marginalized are equally captured by the text, immortalized alongside the power holders and the protagonists to be recognized by future readers who can go beyond the "obvious" narrative and re-construct the voices of the "side" characters and the powerless. Any text, actually, can be turned on its head when read this way.

Silliman as Language poet in BART goes out of his way to capture this heteroglossia as it is, not bothering to coat it with narrative. It couldn't get any more raw as material, capturing even the speaker's commentaries and physical labor and discomforts. How objective could anybody be? Silliman's poem reminds the reader that the writer is a witness. He cannot completely strip away the fact that he is writing from a perspective...but he reminds us, too, that he is flawed. As was stated in the "generalizations" on Language poets: they aim to separate authorship from authority. There is no better poem than this to demonstrate the frailty of the author.

Also, in this poem one finds that language is in transit just as the poem itself is a machine, a machine made out of words. Meaning is as transitory as people going in and out of cars. One is left with text. A long, long train of text that points to the surface of things, reflecting back only the reader puts (or is willing to put) in.

Sunday, November 03, 2013

ModPo 2013 #53 Katipunan Avenue, The Personal Is The Political: On Silliman's "Albany"



Link to text for Albany by Ron Silliman here.
--------------------------------------------------------

"The line is the distance between." I think this pretty much sums up the Albany chapter of Silliman's The Alphabet. With the aid of the video discussion, I pretty much get that the sentences are intentionally jumbled up (inviting reader participation) and that the "between-ness" is the goal of the prose poem. There is no logical point to it except to witness how the self gets created "in between."

These lines were so evocative to me: "Our home, we were told, had been broken, but who were these people we lived with? Clubbed in the stomach, she miscarried. There were bayonets on campus, cows in India, people shoplifting books. I just want to make it to lunch time."

It's a jumble, it's a mix. But there's something so powerful about "Our home, we were told, had been broken" juxtaposed with "but who were these people we lived with?" It's non-sequitur but I can imagine that these two lines make sense to someone growing up in such a home. And then a moment of violence in American history: a woman clubbed in the stomach, miscarrying. It's a piece of trivia. But it is also very personal. Very "in-the-gut" wrenching. What a line to follow a broken home! It's an exclamation point. And then right after, we are whirled from bayonets on campus ("militarized" universities), cows in India (that are sacred and left to roam the streets) and people shoplifting books. These three are so far from each other that the reader needs to find that line, that thin line in between that connects random worlds (and words). It's a mix of rights, ancient and recent, and the breaking of laws. And then that last line: "I just want to make it to lunch time." Who hasn't thought these very same thoughts? The poet invites the reader to draw the lines.

This prose poem will give you a headache...if you expect a narrative. But who wants this much work? I think I asked this question all the way in the chapter on Emily Dickinson. I guess those who want to look into the nuances of words and language. Puzzles with no end.

Here's one for you:

I'll tell you a love story. There are books on the bed. And the Pope is here. And there is some writing on the blue journal. The one with flowers. A chair is thrown. A sleeve is ripped. What is Biogesic for? Give me the keys. I can get out of here now. But where would I go? Look at my cheek. What color is it? Not really here. There's a knife in the kitchen. The note on the bathroom mirror is in black. The grass is all around. There are dragonflies hovering. The letter is stapled. I take a match. My head is exploding. I have a prescription. We smile at the back of the car. Grow up, grow up, grow up.

That was a short response to Albany. Maybe I'll call it Katipunan Avenue. A short excerpt.

I can feel what's being said: the personal is the political. I agree.

Search This Blog